Life is a foundatonal concept.
It is not originated in our mind. Just like we see an object, we understand the life which already working in the living. Foundational concept of life is not seen in the non-living.
Living beings have 3 aspects in their life.
Physical: matter and the fundamental laws and foundational concepts for the existence of matter.
Spiritual : foundational concept of life seen only in the living. So it is not related to matter.
Soulish or mental :it is seen only in the living. It requires both 1)physical 2)spiritual ( life )
"Foundational concepts and fundamental laws are required for the existence of matter and living beings."
ReplyDeleteThough he doesn't know what 'exist' means, he has no qualms in using the term.
A sentient being has to exist before it can conceive concepts. If we use his analogy, it's a child that give birth to its mother.
"Spiritual : foundational concept of life seen only in the living. So it is not related to matter."
ReplyDeleteHow can a concept be seen? May be he is getting hallucinations!
Let us take him on his own words. He says
ReplyDelete1) objects (objects present are that which exist for exist is physical (shape -object) presence.
2) Foundational concept - what objects does like motion.
3) Concepts - idea.
He vehemently denies that god is an object. So he might be saying that god is a 'foundational concept'. (let us forget that whether foundation or roof, a concept is conceived). According to him foundational concept is what an object/matter does. So god is what some matter does. So he is again agreeing that matter is eternal. So again god doesn't exist for god is the one who created matter.